History Study Group (HSG)

  • BLOG
  • SUGGESTED READING

The Cotton Kingdom by Frederick Law Ohmstead

3/7/2023

0 Comments

 
March 16, 2023
Led by Linda Freedman


This book is an important resource as of one of the few journalistic observations of slavery conducted and written before the Civil War. While descriptions of slavery in "Uncle Tom's Cabin" swept the nation, it described life on one slave farm. These writings were an effort to provide a broader observation of numerous farms in several Southern states.

Readers find interviews and descriptions of farms, slaves, slave owners, and farmers using labor methods other than slavery in Southern states. These bring forth many compelling details of 1850s Southern farm lives, without knowledge of the impending war and its outcome that slavery would be abolished. While the descriptions are provided with journalistic integrity, the results helped enrage readers against slavery. While there are slaves expressing varying degrees of satisfaction and misery, and there were slave owners who cared more about their slaves than others (most often in the smaller farms), the brutalities reported about cruel masters and overseers shocked sensibilities. Even Olmsted broke observation neutrality in reporting a debate with a slave owner who noted the law then permitted him to beat both his wife and his slave, so he sees no difference, to which Olmsted felt compelled to reply that the law will act to protect the abused wife but no Southern laws then acted to protect the abused slaves.

Olmsted delivered a mathematically descriptive analysis that slavery was not economically efficient. Paying slave labor low incomes for life produced workers little motivated to work hard. Using violence as a motivation only produced workers who worked at levels just enough to avoid punishment. Slaves farms were further inefficient as owners provided housing and care to slaves for life meant that only a portion of the slave population was economically productive. One farm, rather than risk their life investment in slaves, hired Irish itinerant workers for dangerous work, The author provided examples and data showing that farms that had higher paid non-slave workers were far more productive and more profitable. In addition, the existence of a large number of low income employees was a damper on the Southern economy as they had little purchasing power to purchase goods.

The book editor Arthur Schlesinger notes Olmsted hoped the Southern states would recognize the inefficiency of their slave system and end it on their own accord. He observes some abolitionists denounced these writings for not taking a moral stance against slavery. These were meant as depictions as to what was observed without commentary. They remain as a great collection of slave life descriptions published before the Civil War


Reviewed in the United States on April 10, 2015This is a profound book. It's shocking in its content. It's not any intellectual arguments that make the book great. Just the descriptions of what Olmstead finds day in and day out on his travels is enough. The moment Olmstead crosses into Virginia the roads stop, there are no towns, no infrastructure, and the whole countryside seems primitive. There is no incentive in the South to build civic institutions, even roads. As Olmstead travels deeper into the South, into the new South, the frontier of Mississippi and so on, conditions get worse and worse. To me the description of the poverty of the South alone was an indictment of the plantation system and the independent poor farmers who lived there as well. The book is a bit heavy plodding (for me anyway), but Olmstead can show a sense of humor, and I remember in particular his description of a day in Virginia when he is prancing in delight on a beautiful morning on a fine filly and he gives a blow by blow of his trying to find a plantation house when there are no directions, no roads, but it's the description of the day that was delightful and telling. This type of original source is essential reading to understand what history books will never be able to tell you… what it was really like.

Frederick Law Olmstead travelled extensively throughout the south during the antebellum period, as reflected in this book. He considered the effects of slavery on both blacks and whites and found it to have pernicious effects on both. Although written prior to the Civil War, the book (actually a series of extensive selections from the three original volumes based on his newspaper articles written during his travels)provides a rather indepth and refreshing look at well-known history and looks at the diverse roles played by blacks, white southerners, (and northerners!) in slavery. He also examines their views on the slave issue itself: some nascent Southern abolitionists and colonialists, as well as advocates of slavery, appeared rather intelligent and some otherwise. Many considered slavery an insoluble problem and others defended it as a necessary evil which benefitted blacks and whites alike(!). After completing his tour (including a rather interesting situation in which a black slave seriously injures a biracial runaway, has him clapped in irons and sent to jail - much to the amusement of some white southerners - & an enlightening discussion, especially in light of Talty's research showing persons of pure white descent, including adult foreigners and children who were originally indentured were kidnapped or illegally sold into slavery, of how demeanor would be an adequate determinant of whether or not a "white" slave was really free or not), he provides a critical analysis of slavery and its effects on the south.

====================================================
Critical review--


If you admire Olmstead, this is worth the effort to read his actual impressions of the south. Most of his biographies touch on this, but few explain the importance of this experience in his later life.

​
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Group Leader: Alan Rubin

    Archives

    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    October 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    April 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    May 2021
    March 2021
    January 2021
    November 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    March 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    September 2019
    July 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    December 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    October 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2013
    July 2013

    Categories

    All
    1491: Americas Before Columbus
    1493 America After Columbus
    1919 Boston Molasses Tank Failure
    A Biography
    A Distant Mirror
    Albert Einstein
    American Creration
    A Woman Of No Importance
    Bible Myths
    Blood
    Candy Bombers
    Carnegie
    Caste
    China's Grand Strategy
    China Today
    Cia
    Citizens Of London
    Cotton Kingdom
    Cuba
    Devil In The Grove
    Do Morals Matter?
    Energy: A Human History
    Everything In Its Path
    Facing The Mountain
    Fear City
    Fields Of Blood
    Forgotten 500
    Forgotten-Trump Voters In PA
    God's Shadow
    Greek Revolution
    Heart Of Atlanta
    Henrietta Lacks
    History Shock
    Hitler
    Hitler: A Biography
    How Democracies Die
    How To Hide An Empire
    HSG Blog
    Indian World Of George Washington
    Jane Crow
    Korean War
    Madame Forcade
    Map That Changed The World
    Marshall Plan
    McNamara's Folly
    Mexican War
    Middle East
    Money Changes Everything
    One Hot Summer
    On Her Own Ground
    Polly Adler
    Powder And Residue
    Presidents Of War
    River Of The Gods
    Rough Crossings
    Samuel Adams
    Sapiens
    Second Coming Of The KKK
    Shattered Sword
    Stalin: Waiting For Hitler
    Strangers In Their Own Land
    Thank You For Being Late
    The Back Channel
    The Code
    The French Blue
    The Great Flu Influenza
    The Half Has Never Been Told
    The Howe Dynasty
    The Kerner Report
    The Lives Of The Constitution
    The Moralist
    Theodore Roosevelt For The Defense
    The President Is Dead
    There Is Nothing For You Here
    The Revolutionary: Samuel Adams
    The Rothchild's
    The Sediments Of Time
    The Seventies
    The Woman Who Smashed The Codes
    The Women's Hour
    The Wright Brothers
    Walking With Destiny
    War Is A Racket
    Warriors Dont Cry
    What Has God Wrought?

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly